Saturday, October 31, 2020

Tropical Hainan

Serving the international community on Hainan Island

Is the kindergarten liable if my kid gets hurt at school
Law 

Is the kindergarten liable if my kid gets hurt at school?

Edgar Choi 571 Views ,

Jack and Jill have a 3-year old kid, Alex, and he goes to the best kindergarten in Guangzhou, Happy Kindergarten.

One day, Alex returned home crying, holding his right hand. It was rather red in colour, and Alex refused to eat food out of his bowl at home.

Befuddled, Jack and Jill visited the headmaster, Dumbledore, the next day to inquire about the incident. They suspected that Alex was bullied at school. After an investigation, it turned out to be Alex’s curiosity that killed the cat.

When Alex was being served lunch at the cafeteria, he had wandered off to the teacher’s quarters and pushed over a bowl of hot soup accidentally.
Furious, Jack asked Dumbledore why his son was let near hot soup. Dumbledore replied, “Well, it is his fault that he wondered around and spilt the soup. We told him to stay at the kiddy’s corner.”

Even more agitated, Jack said, “We pay so much tuition fees, and it is the kindergarten’s responsibility to take care of children when they are at school, isn’t it? You have to compensate for this incident.” Dumbledore sneered, “Can’t blame me if it is self inflicted, can you? Say a person doesn’t keep his eyes on the road, and trips over and kills himself, can you blame the government for designing the road? Go ask the soup for compensation, for it burnt your son.”

Who is to blame for this incident?

Law In A Minute

The school is to blame for the incident, and it has to compensate for Alex’s wounds.

Kids in kindergartens are minors without civil capacity and are obviously not capable of taking care of themselves and there is a strict liability imposed by law. Under China’s Tort Liabilities Law, it is the school’s responsibility to take care of them within the school facilities, and any accidents occurred should be the liability of school unless otherwise the kindergarten can prove it has fulfilled its education and management duties. In Alex’s case, it is unlikely that the kindergarten could have any legal excuse.

Legal Basis

Tort Law (2010)

Article 38

Where a person without civil conduct capacity sustains any personal injury during the period of studying or living in a kindergarten, school or any other educational institution, the kindergarten, school or other educational institution shall be liable unless it can prove that it has fulfilled its duties of education and management.

Edgar Choi is author of “Commercial Law in a Minute” and host of a legal-advice account “Law in a minute” on WeChat

Related article: Is an unregistered mortgage agreement valid?

Tropicalhainan.com launched it’s official WeChat account, scan the Qr code to keep up to date with news, sports, entertainment, travel, opinion and more.

Follow us on social media

You May Also Like

Interpretation of the overall program policy for Hainan Pilot Free Trade Zone

State Council approves 18 ministries and commissions to authorize Hainan to pilot national free trade zone policies

Patrick
Can the property management cut off my water

Can the property management office cut off your water?

Edgar Choi
World-class overseas universities invited to establish independent educational services in Hainan

Notice from Dept of Science and Technology to companies hiring foreigners

Patrick
Endangered Black-faced spoonbills spotted in Haikou

Endangered Black-faced spoonbills spotted in Haikou

Patrick
How not to lose money when investing in China

How not to lose money when investing in China.

Edgar Choi
Jeff, Alex and Bob own a consulting company in Guangzhou. Jeff holds 80% of the shares, Alex 15% and Bob 5%. On Jeff’s son’s 20th birthday, Jeff decides to buy his son a new flat. They have their eyes set on a 15 million Yuan flat in West District of Beijing, as that is at where his son studies. However, Jeff only has half of the contract amount, 7.5 mil, so he has to borrow the other half from a bank. As borrowing money requires a corporate asset as security, Jeff decided to use the office. Jill, the accountant was reluctant to provide Jeff with the office title certificate. ‘For whom are we providing this security? Don’t we need to first call a shareholder’s meeting?’ She questioned. ‘For me. I am buying a flat for my son. I own 80% of this company and I am the biggest shareholder. A board meeting will provide the same results.’ Jeff replied. Worried that she might lose her job, Jill did what was told and gave Jeff the office title certificate. Is what Jeff doing proper? Law In A Minute No, it is not proper. Providing any security to a shareholder requires a shareholders’ resolution, and Jeff, being an interested party, is not allowed to vote in this motion. So basically, there is no chance of him getting the corporate security approved unless he can convince Alex and Bob to vote for it, ie the consent of minority. This is to prevent majority shareholders from abusing their rights and to protect the minority shareholders from any arbitrary decisions of majority shareholders. Legal Basis Company Law of the People's Republic of China Article 16 If a company intends to provide guaranty to a shareholder or actual controller of the company, it shall make a resolution through the shareholder's meeting or shareholders' assembly. The shareholder as mentioned in the preceding paragraph or the shareholder dominated by the actual controller as mentioned in the preceding paragraph shall not participate in voting on the matter as mentioned in the preceding paragraph. Such matter requires the affirmative votes of more than half of the other shareholders attending the meeting.

Can shareholders force a company to provide corporate security?

Edgar Choi